25-second pick · +85
Creep Deep Cut
5 letters · 1 word · ~2s to type · 205 accepted answers on the sheet
Skip the poster title everyone already watched. We would type Creep: Deep Cut, +85, 5 letters, about 2 seconds on a keyboard. Do not burn the 25 seconds on A Nightmare on Elm Street, Friday the 13th, Halloween, or Saw — those are Plankton. The trench answer is Sleepaway Camp (+100), but only take it if you can spell it cold.
Trench spelling, only if you already know it: Sleepaway Camp +100
Skip A Nightmare on Elm Street · Friday the 13th · Halloween · Saw